Ian Niven, Manchester City Honorary President describes his best ever City game

The late, great, Ian Niven Manchester City Honorary President and die-hard supporter describes the best game he remembered in all the years, and it was more than 90, he spent following the team he idolized.

The game was a not only a top of the table late season clash away at arch-rivals and reigning champions Manchester United but a decisive game in deciding the winners of the 1967-1968 Division One season.

The text is transcribed from a video recording with Ian, me (a United supporter), and our mutual friend and ardent City fan Phil Bellamy.

FrankWhich is the best game you’ve ever enjoyed at City? Which would you say?
FrankI know it’s difficult.
IanI think it was the night we were talking about.
Frank3 – 1 against
Ian3 – 1
PhilThat was the one at Old Trafford.
Ian3 – 1 at Old Trafford because, to be honest, the score could have been 5 – 1, 6 – 1, 7 – 1 we absolutely were on top. It was like he said earlier on (Phil), the team had to know before they went out they were going to win the game. And I think he, Malcolm (Allison) had actually done his job perfectly ‘cos City were absolutely magic that game. How only three goals went in I don’t know!
FrankSo who scored?
PhilColin Bell equalised. George Heslop got a header from a free kick.
IanI remember the header.
PhilAnd then we got the penalty when Colin Bell was injured, that’s why he was late getting to the pub (Ian was also the landlord of the Fletchers Arms in Denton and had a room dedicated to Malcolm Allison where celebrations were held with the City team after the game) because he was in hospital. I can’t remember if United played with somebody called Francis Burns.
FrankYes, there was a Francis Burns.
PhilYes, Francis Burns chopped him down and he got carried off and we got a penalty.

The match being described was played on 27th March 1968 at Old Trafford before a crowd of 63,004 supporters.


The scorers were:

George Best (1)           Man Utd 1 – 0 Man City

Colin Bell (18)            Man Utd 1 – 1 Man City

George Heslop (57)     Man Utd 1 – 2 Man City

Francis Lee (89 pen)    Man Utd 1 – 3 Man City

The teams were:

Manchester United

Stepney, Brennan, Burns, Crerand, Sadler, Stiles, Fitzpatrick, Best, Herd, Charlton,

Law – sub Aston (64)

Manchester City

Mulhearn, Book, Pardoe, Doyle, Heslop, Oakes, Lee, Bell, Summerbee,
Coleman, Young – sub Connor (89)

The game indeed proved to be decisive. City went on to win Division One that year just two points better than runners up United. It was City’s first Division One title for 31 years since the 1936-1937 season and the last for 44 years until they won the Premier League at the end of the 2011-2012 season when they once again pipped reigning champions Manchester United to the title by an even smaller margin – on goal difference. Ian had enjoyed watching City winning the title in all three of those seasons spanning 75 years – what an achievement, and he would see them go on to win it a further four times.

(Our chat took place during the evening of 23rd August 2021. Ian passed away aged 97 shortly after in December and sadly won’t see City win again this season as they surely will.)

RIP Ian.

2 thoughts on “Ian Niven, Manchester City Honorary President describes his best ever City game

  1. Thoroughly enjoyed your talk today at Glossop U3A – we had a chat beforehand about me briefly touching on the subject in one of my presentations.
    I’m just sorry that there wasn’t a better turn out but hopefully attendances will gradually improve.
    I’ve just read the blog with the late , great Ian Niven, which as a die hard City season ticket holder I found fascinating.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s